Case study

A candidate with five competing offers chose them, and it wasn't luck

Client
Sestra People
Industry
Recruitment / Startup
Country
Australia

Building a team inside a startup is a different challenge entirely. The brief is harder to sell, the competition is fierce, and the margin for error is small. You're going up against agencies with established brands, bigger commission structures, and track records that do the heavy lifting in the room.

When Sestra People came to us, they needed someone who would genuinely buy into what they were building, not someone who would take the path of least resistance and go to the biggest name on their list.

Discovery

We spent time with the Sestra People team getting under the skin of their vision, their culture, and the kind of person who would thrive in a startup environment. Not every strong recruiter is built for it, and placing the wrong person in a business at this stage can do real damage.

We mapped out what made Sestra genuinely compelling as an opportunity: the autonomy, the ownership, the chance to shape something from the ground up. And we identified the profile of a candidate who wouldn't just accept the role, but who would choose it.

Intervention

We found that candidate, and then we managed the process with precision. At the time of placement, they had active interviews and offers on the table with more than five other recruitment agencies. Keeping them engaged, informed, and genuinely excited about Sestra required constant candidate management.

  • Identified a candidate profile built for a startup environment
  • Active candidate management against 5+ competing agencies
  • Regular communication and proactive updates throughout
  • Honest guidance on how to position Sestra against larger competitors
  • Flexible and responsive at every stage of a fast-moving process
"The candidate Managed placed had offers and interviews with more than five other agencies, and they chose us. That doesn't happen without exceptional candidate management and a consultant who's across every detail of the process. We came away with a brilliant hire and real confidence in who we were working with."
Sestra People
Leadership Team

Impact

Sestra People secured a cornerstone hire who had every reason to go elsewhere, and chose not to. That candidate is now helping to shape what Sestra becomes, and the business has a team being built on the right foundations.

In a startup, the first few hires define the culture. Managed made sure they got it right.

5+
Competing offers declined
1
Cornerstone hire secured

Tell us what you're trying to grow

A straight conversation about where the agency is now and what's actually in the way. No pitch deck, no pressure.